Power meter vs smart trainer. Pedal vs crank vs hub.

Power meter vs smart trainer It feels like I am not forced into more aero positions and the training feels unproductive / less efficient at times because of the spin True but a power meter is way more useful for over all performance and training. If the trainer has a power meter. I think the 250W power is not bad for someone who has cycled a bit for a year or so. Feb 6, 2025 · Currently using TR on my original peloton bike (with favero power meter) during winter training and I have been thinking about making a change as the Peloton bike is clunky and frankly a spin bike feels very different compared to my road bike (Cannondale). If your goal is to entertain yourself all winter, smart trainer. I had no power meter, and i just received a pair of assioma duo. You get consistent power data when riding indoors and outdoors. This being said, if you are serious about your bike training, a power meter is a must. For your money id get a used bike, power meter, smart trainer and all. With the power meter and dumb trainer the best use of Zwift is the workouts. This has been a gamechanger in terms of experience. Crankset power meters may affect the Q factor depending on your current crankset. Oct 13, 2021 · It is best to buy a smart trainer before a power meter. Smart bike trainer’s accuracy is without a doubt an important number to look for when purchasing a smart trainer. It will still take x watts for y seconds to move a certain distance in Zwift. My coach recommends roller for recovery only. I’ve got a bkool pro smart trainer, which has been very good to me so far. Power Graphed with PowerMatch (Smart Trainer + Power Meter) Despite these graphs appearing slightly different, both users got the same training benefit from these intervals. That’s why they were invented. Now, I just got my hands on an Elite Drivo II smart trainer and when observing the power numbers from this versus my stages pm the smart meter was about 40watts higher than my stages. The Favero Assioma will be five years old this summer (crazy, huh?), and while the Garmin Rally pedals will be 1 year old in a few weeks, those spindles are basically just the Vector 3 spindles with new pedal bodies. As much as my smart trainer and power meter have both improved my training experience, I think you should just hold off. Retest. Feb 17, 2025 · Pedal power meters don’t affect the Q factor but may affect spindle and stance width. Anyone here records their indoor workouts regularly with both, their bike power meter and their smart trainer? How much do they differ on average in average power? What power meter and smart trainer are you running? Nov 20, 2016 · The most noticeable advantage smart trainers have over power meters in the realm of training, is the variable resistance according to the gear you are in, and/or the virtual road gradient in virtual-world applications such as Zwift. The first power meter was invented by Ulrich Schoberer in 1986. Where I live, weather does not limit me to ride outside any day of the year. If you currently use a classic ‘dumb’ trainer and are serious about your training, buy a power meter to get more accurate power data. But I think a power meter for your main bike is more valuable than the upgrade to a smart trainer. Except for multiple rides when using the trainer, I did an ERG mode test in TrainerRoad , one free ride in Wahoo RGT , and a race in Zwift . Bike chains cause a loss of up to 5% in power when comparing power levels between a power meter and a smart trainer with power measurement. On the other hand, power meter for most outside rides and a cheaper smart trainer to give indoor option sounds like an interesting option too. Thanks! Dec 26, 2024 · I cross-checked Saris H3 accuracy with my Favero Assioma DUO pedal power meters and Magene P505 spider power meter. Sep 29, 2017 · Manufacturers pride themselves on power accuracy. My smart trainer reads ~20w more than my crank power meter. Just started double recording and realized my tacx Neo 2t is showing a lower power number than my crank based stages power meter. Not good at all for the ego, not good at all. I have the Garmin Rally power pedals and I know the reading is not exactly the same so here’s my question: How to do it without mixing outdoors/indoors FTP and different power meters? I will get a new AI FTP in a Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - 2 votes and 17 comments Jun 15, 2021 · I’m in a similar situation. Aug 27, 2020 Product reviews. It makes it easier to ride, ride in bad weather, you can ride at odd times, and you can get a feel for structured training and training with power. Zwift). I managed to fix the difference to 1-2%, was very happy, and did a post about this (TLDR: my Favero Assioma Duo Shi's power readings were low because I didn't have a gap between the pedal . The Sigeyi Power Meter BCD 9900 + A1 Power Trainer 7900 ผลลัพราคา 17800. Browse the best power meters on the market for more info. I’m due a ramp test in a couple of weeks. where and how it measures power will vary depending on the type of meter. I recently got power meter cranks, Qwark, and found the power in Zwift is reading about 15-20 watts less on the trainer vs. 2. I would choose option 3, the power pedals and a dumb trainer. I’ve done 5 or so dual recorded rides, and the Assiomas always record 15-20W higher than the smart trainer power reading. DC Rainmaker Analyzer ZwiftPower Analysis Here is a similar tool and info on use based on the same concept: Golden Cheetah Power Meter Data Comparison Using Golden Cheetah and Excel - YouTube GC Compare Mode on I’m looking to upgrade my indoor training setup in order to get more accuracy on the workouts, and I’m debating between a smart trainer like a kickr snap, or a power meter like a favero assioma. Power for me on the indoor trainer is lower than outside. Always double-check the spindle width of pedal power meters before Jan 17, 2020 · Absolutely regret buying a single sided. Aug 27, 2020 · This is a post about the most common resources and processes to compare at power data from at least two different power measurement devices (such as a Power Meter and a Smart Trainer). Try to only peddle with your right leg as a test. 2W/kg … which sounds too good for me, I guess a number below 4 would be more realistic. I currently use Trainer Road (their guesstimated power) for my indoor training which is the majority of my training and I would like to have a more firm understanding of what my power numbers are and add a bit more consistency to my training. A smart turbo trainer features computer control and either Bluetooth or ANT+ connectivity. I started my indoor training using Zwift and didn't realize my trainer was about 5% off until I picked up a power meter. Today was the first time I used them both together. It's so, so, so much easier to get a workout in -- especially a hard one -- when I just have to pedal. I have a left side crank Stages power meter (gen 2 I believe) and a Wahoo Kickr snap trainer. Power Meter vs Smart Trainer Power I currently have 2 devices to measure my power, a Pioneer single sided power meter and a Wahoo Kickr Core. If power meter pedals have a wider spindle width than your current pedals, it could cause bike fit issues. A smart trainer gives you in essence an indoor power meter which is a significant step up from virtual power. Last night, using Trainerroad and the Wahoo Kickr in Erg, I compared it to the Assioma pedals connected to my Wahoo Roam head unit. Quite honestly, if you are going to use the trainer mostly with Zwift, the smart trainer is a better choice, as it will control your resistances, which makes group rides and regular rides with gradients much more enjoyable (I think) Edit: it also will lock you into erg mode (holding the resistances you need) to complete the workouts in Zwift. Also my average speed is a bit higher in Zwift than outdoors - but I can’t judge this as I’m not slowed down by traffic, turns and corners etc + it’s I always use my on the bike power meter to control the trainer, it keeps my data consistent between my indoor and outdoor rides. I’ve only ever used power-match, but i realized that when i look at the readings between the two, if I’m getting 175watts at the crank, i’m getting something like 140 from the trainer. Right now I have a budget of roughly Jul 19, 2020 · When I finally bought a dual side power meter and smart trainer (which are consistently within 1% of each other), it took me a little while to wrap my head around the 10% drop in my power across the entire curve. I think if you did a crank power meter and a cheaper direct drive trainer like the Zwift Hub you could pay about the same as a new Kickr Core. If your smart trainer allows you to use your power meter to control it, use the power meter as a power source. The smart trainer won't help you outside and having ridden a dumb trainer for years before my smart trainer, the only true upgrade I got was that my smart trainer is wheel off. There should be no expectation that power at the pedal is equal to power at the axle. I cant decide between buying a smart trainer or buying a power meter. the cranks. So on Zwift, I set the controllable + power source + cadence sensor to my smart trainer (Tacx flux s) and at the same time, dual record the ride on my edge 530 with it paired to the Assiomas. Analyse the two data files in sections. Power meters and smart trainers measure power in different ways, so it is natural that the power reported from the two sources will differ. The trainer measure the force at the cassette area where other power meters usually on the pedal or crank are affected by the friction of the chain and Bottom bracket bearings, so the wattage at the cassette will always be lower than the wattage at your feet/pedal… Oct 21, 2015 · I am in the market for a new training tool. Does garmin provide some power training plans when hooked up to a power meter? Apologies for yet another power meter discrepancy question, but would appreciate your thoughts. I then set up TR to run using the Powermatch feature and while the difference was less, the workout Horrible power meter accuracy. If yes, I’d personally much rather have power both inside & outside vs a smart trainer (or especially a better smart trainer). I’m wondering what the best way to get off it is. You will see their power accuracy claims printed in large bold font on the front of the box – if it’s a good number of course. You don’t want a power meter with high volatility (once it measures 190W, then 210W while you ride at 200W, for example). Dec 6, 2020 · So you're in the market to train with power, but which should you buy? Should you pick up a power meter with a cheap "dumb" trainer? Or should you shell out So I have a Cycleops Powerbeam Pro and a Stages left side power meter. Most people would advise you use the same power source/power meter indoors as outdoors for consistency. I have a stages left arm power meter and a Hammer trainer. That makes sense to me as the drivetrain will eat up wattage on the way to the trainer. Pedal vs crank vs hub. I say use power in the right context because, here’s a good example: I woke up sick the day before Ironman Florida (cold, etc Oct 22, 2021 · It is better to estimate your FTP on the trainer if you are going to train there. A percentage of power will always be lost through a chain. A power meter + dumb trainer works fine, all you're really missing is ERG mode, but a smart trainer is nice and lets you not think about things during structured workouts. I understand this difference is due mainly to drivetrain losses between reading power at the crank (meter) opposed to the cassette (trainer). If you're using ERG for steady-state testing, use the 39/16-17 to ensure the flywheel speed is 25km/h-35km/h. The updated algorithm is more accurate and responsive than ever. It's going to be broadly the same as a bike power meter that measures power in the same way. Is there anybody who's used both a spin bike and a trainer and could give some insight? I don't want to spend the $500 on a smart trainer if the gains are going to be minimal. Hallo liebe Freunde des Radsports, ich habe mir vor einer Weile ein Smart Trainer (Elite Suito-T) sowie ein Powermeter (4iii Precision 3) zugelegt. It is using a different sensor that more accurately measures the rpm of one of the internal wheels/axles. If your one of the crazies that trains indoors all year round, then maybe the smart trainer is the better choice. While I had been using my trainer for power readings, my FTP was around 300W for 84kg rider, but now I switched my power source to Favero and my FTP test result today was surprisingly low at 250W. What is the better or expected power measurement for Zwift? Is it best to use what I am putting out at the pedals or what is being put out at my tire? Thanks Zwift community! This place rocks! Dec 18, 2017 · Here's a brief run-down of a day of testing trying to get to the bottom of why I'm seeing some major differences in power numbers (well beyond the maximum combined margin of error) when putting my Garmin Vector 3 Power Meter pedals up against the Tacx Neo Smart Trainer in steady state ERG mode. Some cheaper models estimate power from speed. Nov 25, 2020 · Smart Trainer: Magene T300 Powermeter: Favero Assioma Uno Workout used for testing: Cadence Build I performed spindown calibration earlier today with 10 min warm up before the spindown. You could also get a power meter crank arm for like 300 and maybe buy a used smart trainer (a lot of people buy them, use once, sell) for less. Apr 6, 2022 · It’s been about five years since I’ve last done a power meter pedal comparison post. The internet tells me that I can still use Zwift with a power meter + dumb trainer. You can learn more about this topic in my article power meter accuracy vs. In terms of product recommendations, this is dependent on few factors: Nov 24, 2018 · As a result I’m stuck with using the power form my Kurt Kinetic smart trainer until my new cranks/power meter arrive. But if have to make the choice between the two, here's a breakdown of considerations for each option:Power Meter: • Outdoor Riding: A power meter allows you to measure your I did some quick calcs and this option will save me about $150 if I can get some things used. My 20 minute segment during the test: Elite Direto 331 watts Quarq Dfour Having done a dumb trainer and power meter for a couple years, getting a smart trainer (Hammer) last year, I too agree Erg mode is worth it. The cadence guesses output by the trainer are secondary and the results of them using power fluctuations to estimate rider cadence. Mainly, because not much had changed in five years. Be careful about going If you have both a smart trainer and a power meter i would first check to see what the difference between the 2 units is. I always take my power meter pedals with me when traveling and mount them on peloton bikes in hotels and then use Zwift on an iPad to execute my planned trainings. Also calibrated Assioma prior to workout. Chances are your set up will differ too making it hard to compare data. Direto data being ‘sent’ to trainer road and quarq being sent to the Wahoo Bolt. Just focus on putting out watts, and let the trainer and app take care of the rest. I've been doing almost all workouts inside for the past few months, so I have only used the Wahoo Kickr Core for power. Jun 23, 2021 · Just curious to know what people think is a more important/better training tool. Consistency is key to efficient long-term progress. The Favero Assioma Uno measures power at the pedal while the trainer measures power at the rear axle. I have just always used my power from my trainer for no particular reason other than it was just always set up. A wheel off smart trainer is better, gives you access to erg mode and sim mode (i. Feb 15, 2025 · The power data of a smart trainer and a power meter can differ. If cost is a concern I would recommend just getting a power meter alone. Feb 1, 2019 · Since I was just going to be training with power indoors for the winter I didn’t really care that it was so low as long as it was consistently increasing. A power meter is a very useful training tool IF you have a coach or are able to read up on how to analyze data. I have a Snap V2 and a power meter, and I have found that using the power meter to control the resistance during ERG workout very slow and I tend to overshoot and undershoot the target wattage due to the lag. You'll be able to measure your FTP and structure your training around that. To solve the problem, where my trainer was regularly providing 20+W more than the workout called for, I set Zwift to use my power meter for power reporting instead of the trainer; now when running intervals Zwift will adjust resistance so it stays very close to the workout Feb 5, 2025 · ANT+ Power Meter Profile: This broadcasts as a standard ANT+ power meter, with cadence and speed data baked in. But power is best used for targeted training sessions which are easier and safer to do indoors. Almost every smart trainer and power meter are (on average) in quite close agreement. Heart rate monitors measure heart rate, a lagging indicator of your body’s response to a given effort, and can be influenced by other factors like fatigue. My Satori Smart read about 30 watts lower than my vectors and my quarq. I just bought Favero Assioma Duo-shi PM for my outside rides/training/etc. Feb 22, 2020 · Hi I’ve been using trainerroad one and off for a while. Dec 10, 2019 · Bluetooth Smart Power Meter Profile: This broadcasts as a standard BLE power meter, with cadence data Bluetooth Smart Speed/Cadence Profile: This broadcasts your speed and cadence as a standard BLE combo Speed/Cadence sensor Bluetooth Smart FTMS (Trainer Control): This allows apps to control the Suito over Bluetooth Smart (with cadence/power data) I am aware of many benefits of using a power meter over speed/cadence sensors, however one aspect I am keen to understand is the power. Hi! I noticed a while ago that my Tacx Flux S shows considerably higher watts (something like 30W) than my Favero Assioma Uno power meter pedal. While the power variance is not so bad you can’t train with it I think a lot of problems people run in to is comparing one bike vs another or one bike with a power meter vs a trainer bike with a smart trainer, etc. Is there any point me installing and using the assiomas, that wouldn’t Mar 3, 2025 · This winter I’ve been using my Tacx Neo 2T smart for TR and done exclusively indoors workouts, but as the winter slowly comes to an end I will start doing some endurance outdoors. Anecdotally I have 3 power measurement devices at my disposal, a stages Gen 3 (left only), Garmin Vector 3s, and a kickr core. In the Wahoo app you can turn on “control with ANT+ power meter”. (I have a dumb trainer and other gizmos that enable me to do virtual watts when training inside for winter months) I dont have a power meter and struggle/dont’ like using heart rate on the bike for outdoor rides. Further Tips: Reinstall the Assioma. I know there are different advantages to each, could take the power meter outdoors, could get ERG mode with the smart trainer, but I’m wondering if one is better strictly from the I bought a power meter first, used it on a dumb trainer for a while and got a great benefit from it, ended up buying a smart trainer and after about 4 months I sold the power meter. You can't take your smart trainer outside or to a race. Usually when I'm using speed/cadence sensors on the spin bike, my power gets capped at 400w, which is very frustrating when trying to do training plans or doing general rides etc Sep 24, 2020 · The best option is to get a power meter (train outside) and a smart trainer for erg mode. Also dont forget you NEED a FAN for Zwift, or else your cooked. Aug 27, 2020 · P325 Power Meter; P325 CS Power Meter; G801 Spinning Bike; G601 Exercise Bike; BLOG. It pains me a bit to say but the improvements while definitely there are not so large as to be 100% necessary. Feb 15, 2025 · You won’t find whether your power meter is accurate without comparing the data from your current power meter with power readings from other power meters or devices like a smart trainer. Do a few sprints. Today I tried an experiment: I connected my left-side crank power meter (4iii Precision) to Zwift and used my Elite Suito smart trainer power meter for TR. Id make that work with half of your savings np. What I’m wondering is, when pairing the power source, should I use my existing power meter or the trainer? If I use the PM does the trainer know what resistance to set for erg mode and does it still need to be calibrated?? Also, my HR monitor won’t pair with Zwift. Jan 11, 2023 · I like to ride in Zwift while doing my TR workouts. However, you can buy power meters known for their accuracy and consistency. Furthermore, when you add a power meter to a system that can dynamically control resistance, you can simulate a real-world riding situation (minus the rain or snow, of course). [Power meter $200 Vs smart trainer $500+. With this I can't afford a power meter on my bike. Wahoo has a solution for this. e. I’m assuming this might be due to drive train efficiency. I can only buy one this year. I will get a power meter outdoors, and my power data will be consistent indoors and outdoors. Which would be the better option? I like the simulated grades with a smart trainer, but I don’t like the fact I won’t use it as much in the summer. Feb 7, 2025 · Consistent data are the key to effective training. The trainer is NOT using cadence for power calculations. Alternately, can you set up cycling apps with a spin bike? I'm not sure if I could get a power meter on my bike without a lot of expense. Conclusion. Sep 24, 2019 · Thankfully i invested in a crank based power meter a couple of years ago and revisited Zwift. However i invested again in Feb 2018 and upgraded to a direct drive smart trainer. Ich habe einen Ramp Test und co gemacht, allerdings ohne Powermeter. If not, keep digging. For those of you unfamiliar with the powerbeam it is a traditional trainer setup where automatic resistance is given by the trainer at the wheel. Either clip out on the left or push very little. I’ve tested the power meters against others (pedals vs wheels vs cranks on the bike at the same time) and I’ve never had a significant difference between them - either inside or out However, whenever I record the power numbers I get out of any of the three kickrs I’ve owned I consistently record higher SMART: ERG mode keeps you accountable, making sure you hit every power target in a planned interval workout by increasing the resistance if you slow down, and easing up when you pedal faster. Oct 3, 2018 · I’ve owned a few kickrs over the years as well as a few different power meters. Indoor trainers can incorporate a power meter. My go to is to just use the smart trainer power and then use the cranks outside, makes it for me closer to actual, rather than having to have two different ftps or power targets. Mar 17, 2018 · In addition to power, the cadence trace (the pink line) for the power meter is ‘smoother’ than the smart trainer – This has most likely resulted form the varying resistance applied by the I think what matters most is how useful it will be for you to transfer your indoor training outdoors. Feb 11, 2021 · I’m currently on zPower and it has prevented me from competing in certain races. Smart trainers include a power meter while making your indoor training enjoyable. question i have is do zwift have a way of Jan 2, 2017 · The most noticeable advantage smart trainers have over power meters in the realm of training, is the variable resistance according to the gear you are in, and/or the virtual road gradient in virtual-world applications such as Zwift. 0, exclusively from TrainerRoad. Pedal-based power meters tend to be the most accurate, however, the high-end smart trainers now provide power readings that are +/-1%. I’d tried it with my Garmin and even the Until a week ago I had a 5-7% discrepancy between power readings from my Favero Assioma Duo Shi power meter pedals and my Wahoo Kickr v5 smart trainer. Smart trainer power accuracy usually goes to hell at really high flywheel speeds. งบ 20000 ซื้ออะไรดี ระหว่าง Power Meter หรือ Smart Trainer พรีวิว wahoo powerlink zero Power Meter ตัวแรกของ Wahoo Dare MA-AFO We also carry smart trainers to enhance your training, offering the functionality seen on dedicated indoor bikes with the comfort and familiarity of your own personal bicycle. I see a good smart trainer as a long term convenient indoor fitness solution. Dec 30, 2024 · Cycling power meters have revolutionized the way cyclists train, offering a window into your performance with precise, real-time data. Theoretically, the readout should be the same on your Kickr and your power meter, as all the power comes from the right leg. The only problem is that the trainer is reading something like 40-50 watts higher than my stages, but only when going above around 200 watts. The problem was that I had to consciously control my power output with such precision that it made the workout kinda difficult and very stressful because keeping the power within the target range is pretty difficult. Both the power meter and smart trainer can give incorrect power values, but comparing the differences between the two, using a large enough sample size, could give us some insight as to which smart trainers overestimate and underestimate the effort. Magene P325cs Power Meter + A1 Power Trainer 7900 (+ได้นิด) ผลลัพราคา 21800 ชุด Saver A1 Jul 17, 2019 · Virtual power was a fantastic invention and of great use when power meters cost $2000+ and complicated and expensive Computrainers were the only thing close to a modern smart trainer. Significant differences Dec 6, 2018 · All last season I felt like there was a difference in my perceived exertion at a certain watt level between the trainer and my powermeter. The power meter will be more meaningful when you already have a feel for power from the trainer. The top profile simply doesn't represent the actual fluctuations in power as clearly as the bottom. My power for the ride read 231 from the trainer and 257 from the power meter. If your current setup has been consistent with virtual power you're already pretty set training wise. power meter consistency. Their accuracy is similar to dedicated power meters. Jul 24, 2020 · Potentially a stupid question :). Power meters and smart trainers will always be more precise. Feb 15, 2025 · The main difference between a power meter and a heart rate monitor is that the power meter provides objective, instantaneous data about your effort. Virtual power is still a valuable tool for folks without access to real power reading but by no means did you waste your money getting a smart trainer with real Two ways you could do it - pair the Vectors to the Suito with the Power Meter Link (PML) function and get the trainer to forward the power data (configurable via the Elite app), or set the power input on Zwift to the Vectors and the controllable trainer to the Suito. Best of both worlds for less than the price of a smart trainer alone. I’ve recently started to use a Tacx Flux with Zwift. Jun 8, 2023 · I’ve been using a Wahoo Kickr Snap (wheel on) for a long time using Erg mode and Trainerroad. Power-match makes this For consistent data indoors and out, you can use your bike’s power meter to control your smart trainer with PowerMatch 2. Oct 31, 2018 · I’m definitely a huge fan of the power meter over the smart trainer, but I do most of my training outdoors when it’s nice out. Bluetooth Smart FTMS: This is the industry standard for apps controlling the trainer via Bluetooth Smart, and includes ANT+ power and cadence baked in. Feb 18, 2021 · Hi fellow zwifters, recently discovered on a rzwift meetup with some friends that you can gain 3-4% increase in power output from connecting a power meter to control zwift rather than relying on your trainer. Fwiw, I don't really 'train' outside (apart from cafe and chilled Z2 rides) and when I race I usually race to RPE anyway so in many ways a power meter was totally May 19, 2020 · PM + a wheel on trainer works fine and if you are on a budget and what power all the time is the way to go. Jun 26, 2015 · The power you put out will be the same whether or not you have a dumb trainer or a smart trainer. Devices used: Zwift on laptop via ANT+ paired to Assioma pedal, connected for Power&Cadence&HR only Sufferfest on iPad via Bluetooth paired to Magene T300, connected Apr 8, 2021 · Thats only true for the power meter. However, there are also reasons to buy a power meter, even if you are not hyper-focused on improving your fitness. Technically it’s a smart wheel on trainer, but if you go the smart trainer route, get a direct drive trainer (like the Zwift hub). See if they line up. You will see it as a +/-x% number. Dec 7, 2015 · Has anyone compared smart meters power output with some other power meter (like Garmin Vector)? FTP test on my Elite Realtour gave me yesterday 4. ) Wahoo Kickr Core. In an ideal world, you get both. The only difference is that you might be able to spin 90rpm in the big ring on a dumb trainer, but on a Kickr you might be in your smaller gears averaging 70rpm up a Jul 1, 2017 · Is there a benefit of buying a smart trainer if i have a power meter ? Is the ERG mode a difference maker? Does the smart trainer response to change in terrain on Zwift worth it? If I get one , it would probably be wahoo kickr snap because of financials. Magene P325cs Power Meter + เทรนเนอร์ธรรมดา จับดุม 5000 ผลลัพราคา 18900. A friend of mine recently wanted to start cycling and I got him to test and the result was 220W and he had a running background with a 5k time in the low 17min range. I was interested in comparing the power readings of each so recorded two short (~ 10 min) rides, one before doing a spindown on the kickr and one after Some are noisy, some have complicated setups, but one of the best features is a power meter. Between two exactly the same bikes the readings on the peloton computer can be +/- 25% compared to the PM pedals that are accurate. For those seeking precision, our direct-drive trainers eliminate the need for a rear wheel, connecting directly to the bike’s chain, providing smoother, more accurate Aug 29, 2016 · Big freewheel simple trainer + left arm power meter or expensive smart trainer with built in power meter? I use strava and I like it but if the choice is between recording progress online and a better training program I'd choose the latter. ] Power Graphed with only Smart Trainer. I’m considering getting either a Favero Assioma Uno or a Wahoo Kickr Snap. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned rider, using a power meter can help you unlock your full potential by providing insights far beyond what heart rate or perceived exertion can offer. Easy gear and maybe 500 m. Jan 16, 2024 · On a smart trainer, the power travels through the crank arms and chain before it reaches the point of measurement in the smart trainer. The gigantic advantage of the trainer is the built in power meter which is an absolute game changer in terms of training. Oct 19, 2018 · I have heard this talked about a bunch but no real data. Reviews Compilation: Magene T300 Smart Trainer. If you can tolerate or even like indoor training the trainer will give you more benefits. Feb 15, 2025 · However, there is only so much they can do. So that you are able to access power for outdoor training and racing, and indoors to easily execute workouts and ride virtual courses and engage in group rides and race on various apps. (maybe I’lll buy the other item in a year or two or three - sooner Feb 15, 2025 · The truth is that most reasons to buy a power meter are related to training and performance. Nov 29, 2024 · While smart trainers can offer a more immersive and interactive experience, power meters provide more precise and actionable data that can help improve your pedaling technique and efficiency. So yesterday I decided to ‘test’ them against each other during an ftp test. This year is the first time that I actually get stuck in and really enjoy it. I wanted to compare the differences in power between the two units. If your goal is to be a faster rider, power meter. I was surprised to see that the 4iii power meter was consistently 10-15 watts higher. Trainer all the way. The two on the bike power meters are very consistent with e I had mixed results when I first used my power meter (pedal) as the source and ERG mode with my Kickr Snap. I have a power meter on my bike and in a few weeks I will use the power meter but don’t want to change now in the mid of a training block. So my question really is has anyone done this and did the power match closely? The trainer power is the one that is correct almost certainly. Dec 11, 2022 · I have a Saris M3 smart trainer and really enjoy it. There are several opportunities for loss between the pedals and the axle: crank arm, bottom bracket, chain, etc. Cleats Compatibility May 13, 2020 · Apologies if already asked. Nun zur Überprüfung habe ich das selbe nochmal mit Powermeter parallel gemacht und Zack, 80 watt (400 vs 320) auf 8 Minuten mehr. Power meters will: 1. Wheel on trainers aren’t super accurate but if you have a PM, you’ll just use that for power anyway, so trainer accuracy is moot. Using a bike trainer with a power meter makes the experience better. gkypzg hkbwwy egwo vtn zubm pulgbw zgmrt waait goaj rrehtz jxauvug udtrilny vttsj cwynx liewjgz